The Best Organic Eyeliner You Can Make the Most of (2022 Reviews)

It’s not surprising why more and more people are opting for the best organic eyeliner. It’s taking over social media and the cosmetic industry. After considering over 20 eyeliners, I recommend the 10 organic eyeliners to go.

Either one or a few of them will soon become your personal whisperers. Enhancing the roundness of your eyes and intensifying those eyelashes. This is the best place for organic eyeliners. So what are you waiting for?

Best Organic Eyeliner – Top 10 Choices

best-organic-eyeliner

Photo credit:  rawrawbeauty.com

Are you looking for the best organic eyeliner? Then you’ve come to the right place. These 10 beauty products are all-natural, safe, and organic!

So do you wish to see which brands made the cut? And how you can make your eyes look bold and beautiful? If YES, then read on below.

Eyeliner Name

Our Rating

Main Ingredients

Colors

#1 

Editor’s Choice

Palm and Palm Kernel Glyceride

6 colors

#2

Jojoba Seed Oil

6 colors

#3

Jojoba, Mango, Meadowfoam Seed Oil

3 colors

#4

Chamomile, Meadowfoam Seed Oil, Vitamin E

5 colors

#5

Jojoba Oil, Vitamin C & E

8 colors

#6

Communis Seed Oil

1 color

#7

Jojoba & Castor Oil

3 colors

#8

Organic Sunflower Seed Oil

2 colors

#9

Jojoba Oil

7 colors

#10

Shea Butter

7 colors

All links above will take you to the latest prices on Amazon.com or you can read our in-depth organic eyeliner reviews below.

  1   Ecco Bella Natural Soft Eyeliner Pencil – Editor’s Choice


	 Ecco Bella Natural Soft Eyeliner Pencil for Beautiful, Flawless Liner - Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes - Velvet - .04 oz.

Want to totally change your look in just a few seconds? You have to try the Ecco Bella Natural Soft Eyeliner. This best organic eyeliner is better than your drugstore-bought cheap eye pencil.

This is a non-toxic and superior formula with naturally-preserved ingredients. It enhances your eyes and gives it definition. Any professional makeup artist would swear by this product. And as must you if you want bold eyes!

The pencil texture won’t irritate or sting your eyes. You’re supposed to apply it at the base of your eyelashes. It dries off quickly and stays on for the longest time. The line is neither too thick nor thin.

It gives your eyelashes a good shape and feels. Try this for perfect-looking eyes and you won’t regret it!

The color of this eyeliner pencil is brown. It’s a natural shade that works on all skin tones. It comes in a total of 6 appealing colors. The natural colors are more eye-defining than vibrant ones.

If you want a bolder look, you might have to apply two coats. A single line may look transparent or hardly visible on darker complexions.

Pros

  • It doesn’t smudge.
  • Great for sensitive skin.

Cons

  • The neutral shades are not dark enough.

  2   Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner Best organic eyeliner for sensitive skin


Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner, Jet Set | Gluten Free, Vegan, Paraben Free

I know that applying eyeliner is tricky business. But the Honeybee Gardens Eye Liner makes it much easier. It feels gentle and smooth against the skin. Even while applying it, you won’t feel it pull or drag your skin.

As you use it more and more, putting it on takes less than a minute. Even if this eyeliner becomes your only makeup, it does it perfectly! Unlike other eyeliners that are either too dark or not so dark. The Honeybee gives you the best color for highlighting your eyes.

The creamy texture of the eyeliner doesn’t irritate your eyes. So if you have extremely sensitive eyes and skin. Using this best organic eyeliner might help.

This eyeliner comes in 6 different colors. Each has its unique deep and matte effective. The kind that’s hard to find among hundreds of eyeliners on the market. The eyeliner also acts as a filler that goes with most mascaras.

The eyeliner can smudge a little if you rub it. But so it may not stay on for a long time. Especially if you have oily skin!

Pros

  • Super black and matte effect.
  • Non-irritating and paraben-free ingredients.

Cons

  • The color may lighten a bit after long use.

Honeybee Gardens - Effortless Eye Liner

play

  3   Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner – Best fade-resistant organic eyeliner


	 Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black, 0.04 Ounce

The good news is that among hundreds of toxin-free eyeliners. I found the Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner to be most appealing. It’s probably one of the best organic eyeliners you need to splurge on. And it’s not even that expensive!

This smudge-proof eyeliner redefines eye makeup. It saves the day with its paraben-free and naturally-derived ingredients. Such as jojoba, meadow seed oil, and mango extracts. It feels and smells good.

What makes a makeup product good? It’s when you can use it every day to enhance your facial features. And this nourishing eyeliner does exactly that. It boosts the look of your eyes while adding volume.

It may not be the shiny eyeliner you’ve been looking for. But that’s a good thing!

How many times have you felt cheated by an eyeliner’s color? Well, now you won’t be. The Burt’s Bees gives you the color it promises. The blacks are deep blacks and the browns are natural browns.

The thing about eyeliner pencils is sharpening them. The tip can break anytime wasting a good amount of color. This eyeliner has a weaker tip than most. So you have to be careful when getting it to a sharper point.

Pros

  • Feels soft and even against the skin.
  • It doesn’t chip away for hours of use.

Cons

  • The point keeps breaking while sharpening.

Burt’s Bees Apply The Look – Naturally Striking Eyes

play

  4   MINERAL FUSION Eye Pencil Coal – Best long-lasting organic eyeliner


MINERAL FUSION Mineral fusion eye pencil coal, 0.04 oz, 0.04 Ounce

What separates the MINERAL FUSION Eyeliner from the rest? It’s the eyeliner’s vitamin E and mineral formula. It’s the next best thing to give your skin the care it absolutely needs. While making sure you look and feel beautiful.

It doesn’t matter what time you wear this eyeliner. As the hours go on, it doesn’t smudge or fade. It’s the best organic eyeliner that saves the day. So you don’t have to wash money on expensive mascaras and other eye makeup.

It doesn’t take more than a minute to apply. Even if you’re new to wearing eye makeup! The texture feels soft but not smeary soft. And that’s a good thing, to tell you for a fact.

It just means you don’t have to deal with goop forming at the side of your eyes. Another good feature to take into consideration is the tip. It’s easy to sharpen and runs for a very long time.

If you want to achieve a more natural effect, this is what you need. The colors of this eyeliner are more neutral than bold. They will enhance your eyes without attracting too much attention to the line.

It’s hard to remove this eyeliner with water. It doesn’t even come off, on the same day, after washing. While I like that it’s hard to remove. You might need a strong makeup remover for it to work.

Pros

  • It doesn’t wear down fast.
  • It contains chamomile, vitamin E, and meadowfoam.

Cons

  • It doesn’t come off with just water.

  5   BENECOS Eyeliner Brown – Best non-allergic organic eyeliner


BENECOS Eyeliner Brown, 1.1 GR

A soft touch is never a bad thing. Especially when you have sensitive skin to take care of! The BENECOS Eyeliner offers a good solution for people with allergies.

It contains no traces of harsh chemicals, toxins, or parabens. And it has a softer texture yet remains longer lasting than most. Thanks to the organic botanical ingredients.

This is the best vegan and organic eyeliner on the market. It’s more versatile than you think. Giving you better control over how you want to look. Starting from smoky and bold to natural. It takes on any look you wish to try out for the day.

More importantly, it features a smudge-proof and fade-resistant texture. You can wear it all day without re-applying the eyeliner again for the entire day.

Available in 8 different colors, this eyeliner works in many ways. It gives your eyes a dramatic effect on fancy occasions. Or a natural look on casual days. Be what you want to be in all kinds of eyeliner colors.

The pencil is very, very soft. This makes sharpening it even more difficult. To make sure it doesn’t break, you best store it in the fridge.

Pros

  • Long-lasting and smudge-free.
  • It contains antioxidants and vitamins.

Cons

  • The pencil is too soft to touch.

  6   Avril Certified Organic Eye Liner Pencil Best organic eyeliner for daily use


Avril Certified Organic Eye Liner Pencil (Charbon) Natural Makeup

Finally, eyeliner that feels as good as it looks. The Avril Certified Organic Eyeliner is certified organ and all-natural. It doesn’t contain any animal by-products. It hasn’t even been tested on animals.

Avril is certified and proud in every way. Its natural quality speaks more of it than its claims. With a soft and smooth texture, the eyeliner lasts for a good time.

It is great for sensitive eyes. And you can apply a single line to cover up the entire area. You don’t need to apply it twice to get a bold color out of it. If you want eyeliner you can use every day this is what you need.

For an affordable price, it’s great how reliable this best organic eyeliner is. It doesn’t irritate the eyes or burn. It dries off just as quickly. Plus, you can remove the eyeliner using natural oils such as coconut or castor.

The only color this eyeliner comes in is black. It’s charcoal black which is dark and bold. A single pencil line at the base of your eyelashes. And you’re good to go!

Unlike other eyeliners on this list, this one is not exactly smudge- or fade-resistant. It will come off as the hours go by.

Pros

  • Natural and paraben-free.
  • Affordable and easy to use.

Cons

  • If you touch your eye, it will come off. 

  7   Best Gluten-Free Vegan Natural Eyeliner Pencil – Best plant-based eyeliner


	 Best Gluten-Free Vegan Natural Eyeliner Pencil by BaeBlu, Black

Tired eyes? What you need is the Best Gluten-Free Vegan Eyeliner. It’s the most affordable and natural trick to get rid of tired eyes. It’s easy to apply on the skin and stays on all day.

Nothing about this best organic eyeliner feels lacking. Starting from its bold color to texture. It all pays off well! The eyeliner stays in one place so you don’t have to keep making it darker and darker.

You may not only re-purchase the same color again. But you’ll want more colors out of this one. It doesn’t smudge like crazy. Nor does it burn or sting while putting it on.

Everything about this natural eyeliner pencil feels comfortable. It is a plant-based eyeliner made of safe ingredients. To soothe allergies, sensitive skin, and resist tears.

You can easily control the pigmentation of this eyeliner pencil. If you want a bolder and dark line, you can retrace the line a few times. If you want a controlled light shade, a single line is enough.

The eyeliner pencil is not as generous in quantity as the others. It’s a small pencil that’s no longer than your middle finger. This means it might run out quickly if you use it every day.

Pros

  • Smudge-free and plant-based eyeliner.
  • Free of harsh fragrance.
  • Suitable for oily skin.

Cons

  • The pencil is too small.
  • It might smear if you rub it.

  8   Artisan L’uxe Velvet Eyeliner Pencil Best water-resistant eyeliner pencil


Velvet Eyeliner Pencil by Artisan L'uxe Beauty | Jumbo Eye Pencil for Smokey Eye | Water-Resistant & Smudge Proof | Long-Lasting | Sue Devitt | Black | Midnight

There’s a reason why the Artisan L’uxe Velvet feels like a dream. It’s endorsed by professional makeup artists and celebrities. A youth-enhancing eyeliner pencil, it’s also the best organic eyeliner to buy.

This eyeliner pencil is long-lasting and smudge-proof. It’s formulated with organic sunflower seed oil and chamomile. Not only that, it comes in a special formula that resists moisture. And withstands humidity for a smear-free and non-irritating look!

If there’s a go-to eyeliner pencil that I love. It has got to be this one. The pencil glides effortlessly and stays for longer than 8 hours! If you have sensitive skin, the formula doesn’t itch or sting your eyes.

You can dive deeper into eyeliner art with a pencil like this. So good that you can quit your job and become a makeup artist, no kidding!

The colors that make this eyeliner pencil are great. The pencil contains high-density pigments that give you a full-color payoff. So the color doesn’t fade, smear, or smudge. It stays on your skin for a really long time before you have to darken it. Maybe not even then!

The pencil is wider in diameter than other eyeliners. So you need a bigger sharpener to trim its edges. And this product doesn’t come with one. So finding a sharpener for this big fat pencil can be tricky.

Pros

  • Good for skin hydration and anti-aging.
  • It’s smudge-proof and water-resistant.

Cons

  • Doesn’t include a big fat pencil sharpener.

  9   ZUZU LUXE Raven Liquid Eyeliner – Best liquid eyeliner


Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner (Raven)

Do you want to use eyeliner with herbs? Try the ZUZU Luxe Raven Eyeliner. It stays from morning to night and has a gluten-free formula.

Its all-natural and organic formula feels like a spa. A single swoop along the base of the eyelashes. And you don’t have to worry about tracing the line for a long time.

What this long-lasting formula is also good at is hydration. It keeps the skin around the eyes hydrated without irritating the eyes. You draw the classic straight line or a dramatic wing. Everything is possible with this best organic eyeliner.

The brand claims not to use parabens, hydroxides, and nanoparticles. And I absolutely believe that it doesn’t. As should you!

The applicator of liquid eyeliner is different than a pencil’s. This one comes with a thin flexible felt tip. Making it easy to glide along the skin without smearing.

This eyeliner is not suitable for oily skin. It smears easily if you rub or even go close to it. So this eyeliner is definitely not a match for humid climates.

Pros

  • Lightweight and long-lasting.
  • The flexible felt tip creates beautiful strokes.

Cons

  • The eyeliner smudges on oily skin.
  • It doesn’t stay dry in humidity.

  10   Jane Iredale Eye Pencil – Best crayon organic eyeliner


	 Jane Iredale Pencil Crayon, Black and Brown, 0.04 Ounce

A simple makeup routine is something you get into every day. What you need is an easy to use and quick eyeliner to enhance your eyes. And I have just the best organic eyeliner for you. It’s the Jane Iredale Eye Pencil.

There are no exceptions to this eyeliner. It has a wide variety of color choices. It’s bold and beautiful in its texture. And it lasts for the longest time while defining your eyes.

Are you someone who wants to do a quick routine? If so, the quality and consistency of this eyeliner will suit you. You have to apply it only once. And the color doesn’t wear off unless you tear up or smear it yourself.

You might want to wear the same eyeliner for a night out. So you just have to re-trace the line and you’re good to go! The pencil’s shape gives you good control over your lines. This is what makes it an easy purchase for beginners.

The color tip feels a bit more like a crayon than a pencil. So means you get a smoother line than ever. But what this also means is that you need to be careful while applying. If you press into your skin a bit more, the color will get darker.

Be careful when you use the pencil on sensitive and dry skin. It does get flaky and tugs while putting the eyeliner on. On dry and flaky skin, try using a primer instead.

Pros

  • The colors hold up well for daily use.
  • It resists water and smudges.

Cons

  • The pencil gets flaky when applying.
  • Not suitable for dry skin.

Best Organic Eyeliner: Buying Guide – What You Need to Know

choosing-the-best-organic-eyeliner

Photo credit: girlsonthemoon.net

The factors that make the best organic eyeliner are not that hard to find. The point is to know where to look. That’s what I’m here for.

I’ve found out the best possible hacks to find the most reliable brands on the market. I will let you know which ingredients to avoid. And what makes organic in the makeup department.

But don’t worry; I’ll keep this short and simple.

12 COMMON EYELINER MISTAKES YOU COULD BE MAKING

play

Avoid Ingredients That Aren’t Organic

harmful-ingredients-in-eye-makeup

Photo credit: rd.com

For eye makeup, there are certain ingredients that are harmful. They can irritate even combination skin. So forget about using them if you have dry or sensitive skin.

Any eye product affects the eye in a direct manner. It can sting, burn, or tickle you even if just for a few seconds. That goes to show that it contains strong chemicals that you’d rather do without. That’s why you choose organic over everything else.

Thanks to popular, eco-friendly brands. You can now buy eyeliners without using harmful ingredients.

Silicones

Silicones are what give cosmetics that silky look and feel. As with eyeliners, they keep the liquid and creamy texture intact. They also act as impurities-barrier to keep your pores away from dirt.

But more often than, this acts as a seal to lock in bacteria. So your skin becomes prone to acne, breakouts, and dry patches.

Silica & Kaolin

Silica acts as a mineral to lock in moisture for oily skin. It’s the chemical one prefers if they have dry skin. As it replenishes the skin while nourishing natural skin oils!

Kaolin is a white clay variant used for the same purpose.

Phenoxyethanol

The most common ingredient used in perfumes, soaps, and cosmetics. It’s also an irritant most likely the cause of why your skin burns when you accidentally get perfume on the skin. It’s best to keep this chemical away from your eyes.

Oxychloride

Bismuth oxychloride is another irritate used on oily skin. It is what gives makeup its shiny and shimmery look. But it’s also what can cause breakouts, acne, and irritation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What does eyeliner do?

what-does-eyeliner-do

Photo credit: beautylogicblog.com

Eyeliner gives definition to intensify your eyelashes. It also enhances the roundness of your eyes. Making them stand out and appear bold. Eyeliner, to this effect, comes in a simple pencil or liquid form.

You have to draw a classic line or a dramatic winged curved on your eyelid. You can also use eyeliner on the base of your eyelashes under the eyes.

You can choose from a light to darker shade. The right color such as a deep black or brown can really bring out the eyes. More neutral tones such as beige and light brown emphasize your natural look.

There’s a lot one can do with eyeliner. There are many organic and authentic brands. But knowing how to apply eyeliner is very important.

Conclusion

What do you know so far about the best organic eyeliner? You know that it’s not that hard to find. It’s safe, effective, and all-natural. And what if it burns your eyes or causes skin irritation? Then you’re using the wrong one.

Like so many authentic organic brands out there. I’ve got my eyes on Ecco Bella Natural Soft Eyeliner. In terms of color and style, it is indeed expressive and bold. You can wear it to any social or formal event. It’s the perfect companion for savvy shoppers who care about what they buy.

Leave a Comment